Should You Button a Button-Down Shirt?

Let’s Settle This Once and For All

Link: CraftClothing's Button-Down Polo Shirts

You’ve probably heard the debate: To button or not to button? when it comes to button-down shirts. But before you start playing eenie-meenie-miney-mo with your collar buttons, let’s break it down—because whether you’re wearing one to the office, for a team event, or as your go-to corporate casual look, custom button down polo shirts deserve a little more thought.

First, What Is a Button-Down Shirt?

Let’s clear up the basics. A button-down shirt has buttons at the collar points that secure it to the shirt. This is different from your usual dress shirt, which may have a structured collar but no button detail.

Now here’s where it gets fun—with custom button down polo shirts, like the ones offered by CraftClothing, you’re not just dealing with preppy office wear. You’re getting a versatile piece that can look crisp in the boardroom, laid-back at lunch, and stylish on the weekend.

So… Should You Button Those Collar Buttons?

Short answer: Yes—most of the time.

Buttoning down the collar helps the shirt keep its structure. It prevents the points from flying off in different directions like rebellious teenagers. Especially with polos or more casual button-downs, a fastened collar gives off a neat, clean silhouette—exactly the kind of look you want when repping your brand or team in custom button down polo shirts.

But hey, there are exceptions. Here are a few rules of thumb:

✅ Button Them If:

• You're wearing it as part of a company uniform or event wear.

• You want to look put together and professional.

• The shirt is layered under a jacket or blazer (unbuttoned collars can bunch up awkwardly).

❌ Feel Free to Leave Them Unbuttoned If:

• You're going super casual and relaxed—think beach day or café meetup.

• You're intentionally styling it open for a streetwear-inspired look.

• You’re a rebel with a cause (but hey, you better make it fashion).

Custom Button-Down Polos: The CraftClothing Way

At CraftClothing, our custom button down polo shirts—also known as Polo Jacks—are designed to strike the perfect balance between style and function. They’re customizable, breathable, and built to last. Whether you need short sleeves for hot days or long sleeves for a more formal look, you can design them to fit your exact vision.

Want to add your logo? Embroider your team name? Choose the fabric and cut? No problem. With us, your shirt doesn’t just say you’re part of something, it says you care about quality.

Plus, CraftClothing’s polos aren’t one-trick ponies. You can use them as:

• Corporate uniforms

• Smart-casual wear for your staff

• Event merchandise

• Or your brand’s next big merch drop

So What’s the Final Verdict?

Yes, button the collar if you’re going for clean, sharp, and pro.
No, if the vibe calls for breezy, relaxed, and cool.

At the end of the day, it’s your shirt—and when it’s custom-made just for you, you’ve already got style points on lock.

Looking to get custom button down polo shirts for your team, office, or brand?
Check out our collection here: CraftClothing Button-Down Polos

Let’s start crafting your vision—down to the very last button.